With no reservations we got counter seats on a very busy Sunday night. The staff went out of their way to accommodate us . The specials were awesome, fresh and delicious , the service incredible and the inside was as warm as the fireplace. Just simply inviting. While I miss the old establishment and vintage surfboards I like this place so much more. Great people, fantastic food , beautiful atmosphere and view.

This place is one of a kind! Came with a friend and we loved it! A cozy place with great staff, beautiful Christmas decorations, and wonderful music going. I had the roasted eggplant pesto pizza and she got the oysters, both were delicious, fresh, and great takes on classics. I love this place and I will be back soon.

The service was fantastic- went for the first time last night and truly enjoyed the experience from start to finish. The staff was polite and attentive. Food was delicious, and the serving sizes are very reasonable. Great atmosphere as well. It is clear that they saw the early reviews regarding service concerns and did everything they could to fix it. Would highly recommend. Prices on canned drinks were a bit pricey, but on the whole, an amazing experience. Looking forward to returning.

A wonderful restaurant. I had a pizza, my wife had soup and crusty bread. Both meals were delicious. The pizza was super thin, and was probably most reminiscent of pizza I've had in Italy. We also had a couple of mocktails, which were wonderful. The only trouble was that the night we went was a little chilly, so we couldn't enjoy their deck. So we went back the next night. Another wonderful meal. Me: another pizza. The wife: the meatballs, which she said were as good as the meatballs her mother (of blessed memory) used to make. She has never said that before. I should add, I had a white pie, so I asked for a side of marinade (for crust dipping). It was really terrific. The deck on the water was totally worth going back for. And the service was excellent. They are clearly invested in you having a good dining experience. All in all, a terrific restaurant in every way.

Hostess was great and personable and explained the process to us because it was our first time being at Catbird. Process being you ordered and paid first and they bought food out to your seat. We ate outside which was overlooking a lake It was a hot day but they had fans out which helped. View was nice and breeze was there We got charred kale salad and two pizzas sausage fennel and eggplant pesto were bother really good 12' pizzas (6 slices ) We also had the Blanc and rose non alcoholic beverages Tasty but not for me Beer would of been great So we had a slice and took the rest home Delicious the next day too Great spot for pizza We will be back

This was my first time visiting Catbird. Cute byob pizza joint in residential area of Asbury. Loved the waterfront dining deck overlooking a beautiful lake. Staff were very friendly as well. I ordered the margarita pizza. It was everything! Loved the charred thin crust, sauce and fresh mozzarella. The dough was amazing. They were closing but were kind enough to let me get my order in to go. Great service! I just wish I ate the pizza in my car. By the time I arrived home it was cold but still delicious. I can't wait to return and try the pizza hot next time. lol.

excellent spot for a great dinner view and great quality wood fire pizza! the place itself is cozy and has a nice interior style. the staff and customer service is what really brings this experience next level. aside from the delicious speciality pizza options, they also have great appetizers and specials. We had the mussels, shisito peppers, and Roasted eggplant pizza. was superb! highly recommend dining here

First come, first serve, and they're only open for a few hours for dinner. They have both indoor and outdoor seating, though both are quite warm in the summer weather. You order and pay before you sit. We ordered a salad and two pies, upon the recommendation of the staff, which was honestly, too much food. We had the salad of the day, a spring mix with five half cut grape tomatoes and five slices of mozzarella with a berry dressing. Very underwhelming for the price. I saw the kale salads, and they are much more worth your money. Our pizzas were the margherita and the puttanesca. The margherita was good, standard taste, and a classic. The puttanesca was okay, it just didn't have a distinguishing flavor, until biting into an anchovy. They are very slow, which was the worst part of the experience. We received our salad quickly, but after finishing our salad, it was almost 45 minutes until we got our pizzas.

The former Sunset Landing which has been closed for about a year, was sold recently and has opened recently under new ownership and a new name, Catbird. It's located in the far western part of Asbury Park on the border of Ocean Township overlooking Deal Lake. They are open for a late lunch and dinner at this time. 4pm is kickoff. I must say the staff is very very polite and there when you need them. One can eat indoors or out on the deck weather permitting all pizzas are 12 inches not very large, but quite different. Something that is a little unusual for me is that you pay upfront. The only problem with that is if you're dining and you would like something in addition ( an afterthought ), one would have to go thru the payment part again. I wish the owners luck

Oh yea!!! You order at the counter first and then sit, which i could tell a lot of people weren't understanding at the tables around us but its a very simple process... We sat outside and it was a really beautiful view and super pretty. Inside was very cute too but was a little too hot to sit down on a hot day. To start we got the arugula salad with blueberries and balsamic glaze and it was SOOOO GOOD! My boyfriend got the mussels special with chorizo and white wine broth and said they were absolutely delicious and that the broth was amazing. for pizzas we tried the eggplant and pesto pizza and the meatball pizza. both were delicious!!! the meatball was a little light on the basil but i'm a big basil lover, no big deal haha. definitely coming back to try the rest!! everyone was so nice and had great vibes.